TJC - The Jewish Channel
Home About Us Schedule Video Subscribe Contact TJC
Join Our Mailing List
Sign up for our Email Newsletter
TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors
  • Join Our Mailing List
    Sign up for our Email Newsletter
    TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors

  • Is RCA Resolution Forbidding Orthodox Women Rabbis Halacha?

    by Steven I. Weiss

    Does the recent forbidding of Orthodox women rabbis carry the weight of a halachic decision or not?

    In Tuesday’s conference call about the RCA resolution, leaders were clear in stating that the resolution was halachic in nature and binding as halacha.

    But the Forward finds two liberal advocates who claim it doesn’t. First, there’s Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance, and more noticeably there’s a rabbi who was at the convention, R’ Asher Lopatin, and chose not to oppose the resolution on the basis that it wasn’t halachic, according to the Forward.

    Advocates for female Orthodox clergy, however, pointed out that the resolution did not invoke Halacha, or Judaic law, but instead referred to a more nebulous principle of “sacred continuity” as the basis for the prohibition.
    [...]
    “Everybody’s waiting for fire and brimstone, and what we got was a little burning ash,” said Carol Kaufman Newman, president of the Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance. “And that’s good.”
    [...]
    Asher Lopatin, a center-left Modern Orthodox rabbi from Chicago who attended the convention, said that the purposefully vague language barring female rabbis didn’t go nearly as far as it could have in excluding women from spiritual leadership roles.

    Lopatin pointed out that the resolution does not say that women serving as rabbis is a violation of Halacha, or that it is outside of Orthodoxy. Further, he said that the document does not ban women from the Jewish “clergy,” as distinct from the rabbinate. Asked the difference between the two, he replied, “I don’t know.”

    Lopatin said that he would have preferred if the document said that the RCA cannot “currently” accept women into the Orthodox rabbinate. But he said he was not willing to oppose the resolution on that point.

    So, someone here is wrong about what the resolution represents: it could be Lopatin/JOFA, it could be the RCA, or it could be the Forward, which unfortunately paraphrases instead of quoting on this very important point.

    I’ve got inquiries in to both JOFA and Lopatin on this issue.

    April 29, 2010 | Read more Newsdesk posts. 1 Comment »

    Comments

    1 Comment »

    1. [...] new answer to the question of whether the RCA resolution forbidding Orthodox women rabbis is halachically binding upon members comes from R’ Asher Lopatin, who’s often seen as a leading liberal advocate within the [...]

      Pingback by RCA Member: Resolution Forbidding Orthodox Women Rabbis Wasn’t Presented as “Halacha” - TJC Newsdesk — April 30, 2010 @ 11:34 am

    RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

    Leave a comment





    © 2008 The Jewish Channel. All rights reserved.

    Follow the news with the TJC team. Weekly news webcasts and regular updates.

    E-mail us:

  • Blogroll