TJC - The Jewish Channel
Home About Us Schedule Video Subscribe Contact TJC
Join Our Mailing List
Sign up for our Email Newsletter
TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors
  • Join Our Mailing List
    Sign up for our Email Newsletter
    TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors

  • RCA Member: Resolution Forbidding Orthodox Women Rabbis Wasn’t Presented as “Halacha”

    by Steven I. Weiss

    A new answer to the question of whether the RCA resolution forbidding Orthodox women rabbis is halachically binding upon members comes from R’ Asher Lopatin, who’s often seen as a leading liberal advocate within the group.

    In response to an inquiry, he wrote me that, “When the resolution was
    presented, it was presented as is – on purpose without a binding commentary
    that would force you to understand it as halachic or not.” Lopatin said that if the resolution had been presented as halachic in nature, “I would have voted against it and argued against it.”

    Full Q&A with Lopatin is after the jump.

    1) Did the RCA represent the resolution to the membership as either halachic or non-halachic, or was there no statement about its halachic nature?

    During the course of the conference, most speakers – including all those on a panel opening the conference – said that we were not dealing with a halachic prohibition. On the other hand, at least one major speaker said that it was a serious halachic violation. When the resolution was presented, it was presented as is – on purpose without a binding commentary that would force you to understand it as halachic or not. In other words, the resolution was written and presented in a way which was open to either interpretation.

    2) Do you indeed think the resolution is not binding upon members as halacha?

    Yes. I don’t even know what that means: Is the RCA a body that can “paskin” – rule – a halacha? In fact, a controversial halachic committee of the RCA was recently disbanded. The RCA is not a Beit Din nor a Halachic authority. It is a rabbinic organization devoted to furthering Torah.

    3) If the RCA had represented the resolution as binding halacha at the convention, would you have opposed the resolution?

    I would have voted against it and argued against it if it would have said that ordaining a women to be a rabbi was halachically prohibited. I follow the authorities who are leaders in the RCA itself who argue that it is not halachically prohibited.

    4) What are your thoughts on the RCA’s representation to reporters of
    the resolution as binding halacha?

    Everyone is trying to do the right thing and keep a great organization and a great group of Orthodox rabbis united. I support that. I also think that every member of the RCA, and perhaps anyone reading the resolution, has a right to interpret it as they see fit. Nechama Leibowitz argued that it might be impossible to say there is one “pshat” of anything. Certainly, there probably is not one “p’shat” of this resolution. Everyone interpreting it, though, should recognize that in explaining it they are giving only their read of it, and they have to recognize that there might be
    other legitimate interpretations. Frankly, it was clear at the meeting that that was exactly the way the document was written – to allow for a multitude of interpretations.

    April 30, 2010 | Read more Newsdesk posts. 2 Comments »

    Comments

    2 Comments »

    1. [...] response to an RCA member’s saying the resolution forbidding Orthodox women rabbis wasn’t presented …, I sent an inquiry to the RCA asking for clarification, since R’ Shmuel Goldin told reporters [...]

      Pingback by RCA: Resolution Forbidding Orthodox Women Rabbis Is Not Halachically Binding - TJC Newsdesk — May 5, 2010 @ 10:22 am

    2. [...] contrast to the resolution of the mainstream Orthodox Rabbinical Council of America’s resolution forbidding Orthodox women rabbis, this resolution from the International Rabbinic Fellowship — a more-liberal group about 1/3 [...]

      Pingback by Orthodox Rabbinical Group Outlines Women’s Roles as “Clergy” and More - TJC Newsdesk — July 6, 2010 @ 10:41 am

    RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

    Leave a comment





    © 2008 The Jewish Channel. All rights reserved.

    Follow the news with the TJC team. Weekly news webcasts and regular updates.

    E-mail us:

  • Blogroll