TJC - The Jewish Channel
Home About Us Schedule Video Subscribe Contact TJC
Join Our Mailing List
Sign up for our Email Newsletter
TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors
  • Join Our Mailing List
    Sign up for our Email Newsletter
    TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors

  • Leading Open Orthodox Rabbi Defends Alleged “Indiana Jones” Fraudster

    by Steven I. Weiss

    The big Jewish crime news today is that of the “Indiana Jones Rabbi” arrest. R’ Menachem Youlus, who told grand stories of recovering Torahs that survived the Holocaust, has been indicted for having allegedly woven false stories, and inflated invoices and personal financial claims to get more money than he was entitled to from the Save a Torah organization (overall, he’s been found to have received more than $1 million of the $1.2 million the organization raised from 2004 to 2010).

    Now, a leading rabbi in the liberal Orthodox movement that describes itself as “Open Orthodoxy” is taking to Facebook to defend Youlus in multiple posts over the past 24 hours. First, R’ Shmuel Herzfeld linked to the WSJ account and stated “Rabbi Youlis [sic] is in my prayers.” Herzfeld elaborated on his sentiments in a comment to that thread, saying:

    if we are going to charge rabbis for fraud for embelleshing stories when they fund raise…oh my…the prisons will be filled with fundraisers from all different faiths

    That was on Wednesday afternoon. Later on Wednesday, Herzfeld doubled-down on his statements with a new post on Facebook linking the WJW account and writing:

    if fundraisers can be charged with fraud for exaggerating their stories, then perhaps rabbis can be charged for fraud for telling a story in a synagogue appeal/dvar torah that is not exactly true

    At this point, some of Herzfeld’s Facebook friends began to push back against Herzfeld’s repeated defenses of Youlus. Andy Marcus wrote in Herzfeld’s thread that “these allegations go way beyond a fundraiser exaggerating stories…these are accusation of lying and stealing a lot of money.” Roy A. Ackerman chimed in, “I’m with Andy, Rav. Did you read the story in the Washington Post a few months ago?”

    Though these comments were posted 16 and 5 hours ago, respectively, Herzfeld has yet to respond to either. Instead, earlier today, Herzfeld posted yet again about the Youlus case, to point out an inaccuracy in the NYT’s story in a new Facebook post:

    nyt is wrong. “Instead, prosecutors accused him of selling fake Torahs”– The Torahs are all %100 kosher, its their historical origins that are being questioned. should we question the claim the Church makes about relics as well?

    Herzfeld was again challenged by two of his Facebook friends, Andy Marcus and Adam Seth Bashein, the latter of which wrote, “The challenge is that the stories gave the Torahs added meaning and potential value to the buyers.”

    Herzfeld is a leading rabbi in the movement that’s trying to change various of Orthodoxy’s fixed ways, and of particular relevance here, is trying to instill a greater degree of social responsibility among the Orthodox overall. Herzfeld, for example, has endorsed the Open Orthodox-led group Uri L’Tzedek, which has led boycotts and other campaigns against the slaughterhouse that was owned by the convicted bank fraudster Shalom Rubashkin: “Just like we are careful that the food that goes into our mouths is Kosher, so too we must be careful that the person who is bringing us our food and preparing our food is treated in a manner that is fully consistent with Halakhah.”

    Herzfeld achieved a greater relevance in this movement with his 2008 NYT Op-Ed, in which he wrote of the unfolding immigration case against Agriprocessors:

    Unfortunately, the responses of the leading Orthodox organizations, the Rabbinical Council of America and the Orthodox Union, have, in my opinion, fallen far short of what is needed to be done and have done little to diminish the extent of the desecration of God’s name. I am a member of both groups, but I am dissatisfied with their stance, which asks us to sit back patiently and wait for the results of a federal investigation. On some level, this might be prudent, but on another it is unacceptable.

    In a summer that’s seen a great quantity of ultra-Orthodox crime news, a major topic of discussion has been the position maintained by many leading ultra-Orthodox rabbis that alleged abuse and similar crimes should be reported first to a rabbi, who can then determine if contacting the police is appropriate and necessary. The obvious concern is that a rabbi is not capable of conducting criminal investigations, and will tend to have a bias toward other rabbis.

    For many years, I’ve argued that any effort at rabbinic oversight is only as strong as any one rabbi’s willingness to condemn their closest colleague.

    Herzfeld’s advocacy here reveals just how the world of Open Orthodoxy is open to these same problems we see in the ultra-Orthodox world.

    Screenshots of all the Facebook conversations as of the time of publishing are below.

    August 25, 2011 | Read more Newsdesk posts. 5 Comments »

    Comments

    5 Comments »

    1. [...] Leading Open Orthodox Rabbi Defends Alleged “Indiana Jones” Fraudster ▪ New issue of Tradition is now online ▪ Introducing YU 2.0 ▪ Modern Orthodoxy’s Human [...]

      Pingback by News & Links | Hirhurim – Torah Musings — August 25, 2011 @ 8:43 am

    2. [Public] Facebook update:

      “clarification of my thoughts on Rabbi Youlus
      by Shmuel Herzfeld on Friday, August 26, 2011 at 12:54pm”

      https://www.facebook.com/notes/shmuel-herzfeld/clarification-of-my-thoughts-on-rabbi-youlus/256213191067621

      “Since my views on the arrest and indictment of Rabbi Youlus have been misunderstood i want to offer a brief clarification for now. (Any misunderstanding of my previosuly stated views is entirely my fault and i apologize for that).
      1) Rabbi Youlus is innocent until proven guilty. He is entitled to a vigorous defense.
      2)The actual indictment is not even posted yet. So any thoughts about this case are premature (including the thoughts i previously posted). If fraud was committed then that is wrong and sinful and a great embarrasment of God’s name.
      3) My comments about the prosecutor’s case and the NYT article should not be construed as a defense of lying — God forbid! They were an attempt to highlight an aspect of what i thought might be prosecutorial overreach. Those comments on my part were also premature. My initial reaction was disbelief and deep sadness and i thus offered public comments when i should have waited.
      4) Rabbi Youlus and his family are in my prayers. I know him personally and consider him a friend. I also know that he has done many many good things for the Jewish community and he has helped me personally on many occasions (these things do not excuse fraud) so I pray with all my heart that these allegations are false.”

      Comment by Joel Katz — August 26, 2011 @ 2:28 am

    3. [...] rabbi who defended “Indiana Jones” Rabbi Menachem Youlus has deleted the Facebook notes that were discussed in that post, and in their place [...]

      Pingback by Open Orthodox Rabbi Deletes “Indiana Jones” Rabbi Defenses, Posts Response - TJC Newsdesk — August 26, 2011 @ 8:55 am

    4. Mr. Weiss – I am afraid that you have relied, in part, on my words to make a point with which I disagree, namely a criticism of “open Orthodoxy” in general and Rabbi Herzfeld in particular as loosing some kind of moral compass or advocating the covering up of crimes. I don’t think that. To the contrary, Rabbi Herzfeld, at our shul, Ohev Shalom Talmud Torah, and in the community does not shrink from rigorous debate, not only on Torah, but also in political affairs. Disagreement about this or that is respected, not discouraged. This is one of the things I love most about this righteous Jew, in addition to his strong moral compass and dedication to Torah Judaism. This rabbi, more than any other human being, has brought me closer to the Torah and in the process the Creator of the Universe. To the extent that I can do good in this world through mitzvot, it is to his merit, please G-d! Let’s not get too carried away when we disagree on matters. That’s a healthy thing, I think.

      Comment by Andy Marcus — August 27, 2011 @ 6:06 pm

    5. And the clock on your website is off – I do not post on the internet during Shabbos!

      Comment by Andy Marcus — August 27, 2011 @ 6:08 pm

    RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

    Leave a comment





    © 2008 The Jewish Channel. All rights reserved.

    Follow the news with the TJC team. Weekly news webcasts and regular updates.

    E-mail us:

  • Blogroll