TJC - The Jewish Channel
Home About Us Schedule Video Subscribe Contact TJC
Join Our Mailing List
Sign up for our Email Newsletter
TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors
  • Join Our Mailing List
    Sign up for our Email Newsletter
    TJC Blogs
  • The Docent
  • TJC Newsdesk
  • TJC Movies
  • America & World Jewry
  • Feature Films
  • History &
    Remembrance
  • Israel
  • TJC Original Series
  • Row J
  • The Salon
  • Up Close
  • Holy Dazed
  • Inside the Issues
  • Jews of Color
  • Modern Jewish Mom
  • The Portion
  • Rabbis Roundtable
  • Srugim
  • TJC Movie Talk
  • With the Editors

  • Broyde’s Character Fabricated Rabbinic Ordination for Admission to IRF

    by Steven I. Weiss

    The fake identity created by a rabbinic court judge and Emory University law professor who was revealed in an investigation by The Jewish Channel to be Rabbi Michael Broyde provided false claims of having received rabbinic ordination from a prominent sage in order to gain admission to a rival rabbinic group.

    The fake identity of Rabbi Hershel Goldwasser wrote to scholarly journals, was cited in a prominent new prayerbook, and joined an upstart rabbinic group that rivaled Broyde’s own. Broyde has admitted to having been Goldwasser, and all e-mails from Goldwasser cited in The Jewish Channel’s reporting come from Atlanta-based Internet Protocol, or IP, addresses also used by Broyde.

    Goldwasser joined the International Rabbinic Fellowship, or IRF, in the months when it was just beginning to formalize itself as a group and when it launched a members-only e-mail listserv. The IRF was launched as a more-liberal rival to the group of which Broyde has been a member, and on whose rabbinical court he presided as a judge, the Rabbinical Council of America, or RCA.

    In the summer and fall of 2009, the IRF began to more formally authorize each of the more than 100 members who had joined at that time. Each member was asked to submit a form that identified their basic personal details, including mailing addresses, as well as to certify that they had received rabbinic ordination from a recognized seminary or rabbi.

    According to a copy of Goldwasser’s application obtained by The Jewish Channel, Goldwasser’s application asserted that he had received rabbinic ordination, or semicha, from Rabbi Yehuda Gershuni at Yeshiva Eretz Yisrael in Brooklyn, in 1957.

    Gershuni is a significant Orthodox sage who had lived in Israel and the United States, and died in 2000.

    The Goldwasser character made repeated reference to learning under Gershuni in e-mails to the IRF’s members-only e-mail listserv. In a November 2009 e-mail from an Emory University IP address Broyde has used, the Goldwasser character declared, “I learned in Yeshiva for many years many years ago, got semicha from Rav Yehuda Gershuni zt”l decades ago, dabbled in rabbanus for many years, but always earned by [sic] living as an accountant. I am now retired, living in Beer Sheva and my neighbors think of me as a retired accountant.”

    The subject of that e-mail was a debate within the IRF regarding what kind of clergy should be admitted to the IRF, and specifically the question of including women, as the first female Orthodox rabbi, Sara Hurwitz, had months before been ordained with the novel title “maharat.” Some months later, she would be given the title, “rabba,” a female form of “rabbi.” Broyde had written an article for The Jewish Press in July 2009 celebrating the idea of women clergy, so long as they did not take the title of “rabbi.” Broyde would go on to criticize the choice to give Hurwitz the title “rabba,” and the Goldwasser character lobbied Hurwitz from within the IRF to go back to her first title, of “maharat.”

    In a July 2010 e-mail to the listserv, also from the Emory University IP address, Goldwasser wrote about an episode “in the 1950’s…when I was learning in Rav Gershuni’s Yeshiva.”

    A statement from the IRF released on Sunday discussed the Goldwasser character’s membership:

    Prior to the formal incorporation of the organization, when the IRF lacked a formal membership committee, R. Broyde joined the IRF as a provisional member under an assumed name and participated in the closed listserve under that false name. In November 2009 following the adoption of our organizational by-laws and the formalization of our membership procedures, all members were formally vetted and their applications were re-evaluated. Suspicions arose regarding one particular name and whether it was a real person.

    Vigorous efforts were made to contact that person and verify his identity but these were not successful. Subsequently, in 2010, that person was dropped from the rolls of the IRF and excluded from the listserve.

    Here is the actual form provided by Goldwasser to the IRF.

    April 17, 2013 | Read more Newsdesk posts. 12 Comments »

    Comments

    12 Comments »

    1. Steven- Very interesting article, indeed. Would you be willing to explain how you were able to obtain these IP addresses and match them up with certainty?

      Comment by Aaron Freed — April 17, 2013 @ 9:20 am

    2. Aaron – I can’t compromise my sources.

      Comment by Steven I. Weiss — April 17, 2013 @ 9:23 am

    3. Did you have permission to gain access to those emails? Did your sources have permission to gain access to them? Are any parties in violation of a TOS agreement? Just curious.

      Comment by Aaron Freed — April 17, 2013 @ 9:36 am

    4. Also, why is the timestamp off by 4 hours on these comment posts? You should look into that.

      Comment by Aaron Freed — April 17, 2013 @ 9:39 am

    5. As near as I can tell, that address is a highway with no houses. FWIW.

      Comment by Nachum — April 17, 2013 @ 11:01 am

    6. Nachum – Right, it might not be a real address, but we haven’t finished looking into that.

      Comment by Steven I. Weiss — April 17, 2013 @ 11:21 am

    7. Under international protocols web service providers forward IP addresses to a central index. Various web services run searches these directories like a telephone book. Any comment (like this one) shows up on the receiver’s logbook, as well as in the log of any machines through which the message passed on its way through the internet. That is unless one uses various techniques, but even then, its “iffy” to hide. It basically depends on the level of skill of the person who wants to find you whether you are caught. For example, the log on my mailserver shows various folks trying to log onto my email from places that I would never dream of going. Having secured my email passwords, the log of the failed attempts enables me to determine their internet provider and send the internet provider a complaint, which they MUST honor under various international protocols.

      Comment by More internet savvy than Mick. — April 17, 2013 @ 6:38 pm

    8. Something is very strange here. According to this, Rabbi Broyde filled out On application in 2009, Claiming to have received semicha in 1957. One would have to be, let us say, at least 21 years old to receive semicha. That means the person who was applying – to a young organization, and actively participating in list serves – was 73 years old?! That didn’t immediately trigger suspicion??

      Maybe Rabbi Broyde was indeed joking all along.

      Comment by DF — April 17, 2013 @ 9:05 pm

    9. You are milking this half story way too hard, SIW. What does this add to the picture of Broyde’s mendacity other than some more humor? We are all happy that you got some nice little comment IPs from Shamarya and Gil, but at this point you’re cannibalizing your own story with picayune details. Soon we will wonder if you are a bigger troll than Broyde!

      Comment by chakira — April 17, 2013 @ 9:16 pm

    10. Josh – https://www.facebook.com/elli.fischer/posts/10101722293546778

      Comment by Steven I. Weiss — April 17, 2013 @ 9:28 pm

    11. I am missing your point,

      Comment by chakira — April 17, 2013 @ 9:41 pm

    12. Remember, this man is a LICENSED ATTORNEY IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK.

      The act allegedly committed is uttering a false document.

      Now, whether this is sufficient to get one kicked out of the NY Bar is another matter.

      WOULD YOU WANT ANY ATTORNEY WITH THESE STANDARDS REPRESENTING YOU TO A COURT, OR INVOLVED IN A COMPLEX BUSINESS TRANSACTION?

      Comment by Toco Hills Red Neck. — April 18, 2013 @ 2:39 pm

    RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

    Leave a comment





    © 2008 The Jewish Channel. All rights reserved.

    Follow the news with the TJC team. Weekly news webcasts and regular updates.

    E-mail us:

  • Blogroll